Commentary: Abe's watered-down apology fails sincerity test
English.news.cn   2015-08-14 19:02:29

Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe speaks during a news conference in Tokyo, Aug. 14, 2015. In a statement on Friday marking the 70th anniversary of the end of World War II, Abe mentioned previous governments' apology for Japan's wartime past, but refrained from offering his own apology. He also said that Japan must not let its future generations "be predestined to apologize." (Xinhua/Ma Ping)

Click here for more photos>>

by Xinhua Writer Tian Dongdong

BEIJING, Aug. 14 (Xinhua) -- By mentioning the Japanese government's previous apologies in his WWII anniversary statement Friday, Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe hopes to take a step forward toward reconciliation with his country's neighbors.

Yet given the carefully calibrated context into which he has embedded those too-fundamental-to-avoid terms, the apology was a diluted one at best, thus marking only a crippled start to build trust among its neighbors.

Closely watched both at home and abroad, Abe trod a fine line with linguistic tricks, attempting to please his rightwing base on the one hand and avoid further damage in Japan's ties with its neighbors on the other.

The watered-down statement, in essence, is a retrogression from the 1995 statement by then Prime Minister Tomiichi Murayama, which bravely and honestly admitted Japan's war past and expressed "deep remorse" and a "heartfelt apology" for its war crimes.

Instead of offering an unambiguous apology, Abe's statement is rife with rhetorical twists like "maintain our position of apology", dead giveaways of his deep-rooted historical revisionism, which has haunted Japan's neighborhood relations.

By adding that it is unnecessary for Japan's future generations to keep apologizing, Abe seemed to say that his once-for-all apology can close the page of history.

However, those countries which suffered from Japan's aggression would never forget that dark period of history, as Japanese would always remember the horrific scenes of A-bombed Hiroshima and Nagasaki.

The tuned-down apology is not of much help to eliminating Tokyo's trust deficit. It fails to firm up -- if not serving to further undercut -- the credibility the Abe government needs to put Japan's interaction with its Asian neighbors back on track.

Thus the "normal country" dream Abe has long been trumpeting gets no closer. The way leading to that goal cannot be paved by reluctance to extend an unalloyed apology for the atrocities committed by imperial Japan.

Abe should bear in mind that no real reconciliation in East Asia will be possible so long as Tokyo is viewed as a denier of its past crimes, an image he has repeatedly helped forge by, among others, visiting the controversial Yasukuni Shrine and whitewashing Japan's war past.

Given Abe's record on the sensitive history issue, the adulterated apology is far from being enough for Japan's neighbors and the broader international community to lower their guard.

For the sake of Japan's future and Asia's stability, the world should continue its scrutiny on Japan's words and deeds on the history issue and join hands in helping Abe move in the correct direction.

Related:

Japanese PM Abe refrains from offering his own apology for wartime atrocities

TOKYO, Aug. 14 (Xinhua) -- Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe on Friday refrained from offering his own apology for Japan's past atrocities during World War II.

In a statement marking the 70th anniversary of the end of the WWII, Abe mentioned the Japanese government's previous apology and deep remorse, but added that it is unnecessary for Japan's future generations to keep apologizing for the country's wartime past. Full Story

Abe says Japan's future generations unnecessary to keep apologizing for wartime atrocities

TOKYO, Aug. 14 (Xinhua) -- Prime Minister Shinzo Abe on Friday mentioned the Japanese government's previous apology, but added that it is unnecessary for Japan's future generations to keep apologizing for its atrocities during World War II.

In a statement marking the 70th anniversary of the end of WWII, Abe said Japan has apologized for the previous war and the country will maintain stances of the previous governments. Full Story

Editor: Tian Shaohui
Related News
Xinhuanet

Commentary: Abe's watered-down apology fails sincerity test

English.news.cn 2015-08-14 19:02:29

Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe speaks during a news conference in Tokyo, Aug. 14, 2015. In a statement on Friday marking the 70th anniversary of the end of World War II, Abe mentioned previous governments' apology for Japan's wartime past, but refrained from offering his own apology. He also said that Japan must not let its future generations "be predestined to apologize." (Xinhua/Ma Ping)

Click here for more photos>>

by Xinhua Writer Tian Dongdong

BEIJING, Aug. 14 (Xinhua) -- By mentioning the Japanese government's previous apologies in his WWII anniversary statement Friday, Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe hopes to take a step forward toward reconciliation with his country's neighbors.

Yet given the carefully calibrated context into which he has embedded those too-fundamental-to-avoid terms, the apology was a diluted one at best, thus marking only a crippled start to build trust among its neighbors.

Closely watched both at home and abroad, Abe trod a fine line with linguistic tricks, attempting to please his rightwing base on the one hand and avoid further damage in Japan's ties with its neighbors on the other.

The watered-down statement, in essence, is a retrogression from the 1995 statement by then Prime Minister Tomiichi Murayama, which bravely and honestly admitted Japan's war past and expressed "deep remorse" and a "heartfelt apology" for its war crimes.

Instead of offering an unambiguous apology, Abe's statement is rife with rhetorical twists like "maintain our position of apology", dead giveaways of his deep-rooted historical revisionism, which has haunted Japan's neighborhood relations.

By adding that it is unnecessary for Japan's future generations to keep apologizing, Abe seemed to say that his once-for-all apology can close the page of history.

However, those countries which suffered from Japan's aggression would never forget that dark period of history, as Japanese would always remember the horrific scenes of A-bombed Hiroshima and Nagasaki.

The tuned-down apology is not of much help to eliminating Tokyo's trust deficit. It fails to firm up -- if not serving to further undercut -- the credibility the Abe government needs to put Japan's interaction with its Asian neighbors back on track.

Thus the "normal country" dream Abe has long been trumpeting gets no closer. The way leading to that goal cannot be paved by reluctance to extend an unalloyed apology for the atrocities committed by imperial Japan.

Abe should bear in mind that no real reconciliation in East Asia will be possible so long as Tokyo is viewed as a denier of its past crimes, an image he has repeatedly helped forge by, among others, visiting the controversial Yasukuni Shrine and whitewashing Japan's war past.

Given Abe's record on the sensitive history issue, the adulterated apology is far from being enough for Japan's neighbors and the broader international community to lower their guard.

For the sake of Japan's future and Asia's stability, the world should continue its scrutiny on Japan's words and deeds on the history issue and join hands in helping Abe move in the correct direction.

Related:

Japanese PM Abe refrains from offering his own apology for wartime atrocities

TOKYO, Aug. 14 (Xinhua) -- Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe on Friday refrained from offering his own apology for Japan's past atrocities during World War II.

In a statement marking the 70th anniversary of the end of the WWII, Abe mentioned the Japanese government's previous apology and deep remorse, but added that it is unnecessary for Japan's future generations to keep apologizing for the country's wartime past. Full Story

Abe says Japan's future generations unnecessary to keep apologizing for wartime atrocities

TOKYO, Aug. 14 (Xinhua) -- Prime Minister Shinzo Abe on Friday mentioned the Japanese government's previous apology, but added that it is unnecessary for Japan's future generations to keep apologizing for its atrocities during World War II.

In a statement marking the 70th anniversary of the end of WWII, Abe said Japan has apologized for the previous war and the country will maintain stances of the previous governments. Full Story

[Editor: huaxia]
010020070750000000000000011100001345180611