Xinhuanet

German expert doubts arbitral court's jurisdiction over South China Sea dispute

Source: Xinhua 2016-07-04 09:51:12
[Editor: huaxia]

BERLIN, July 3 (Xinhua) -- The real nature of a dispute between China and the Philippines over the South China Sea is about territorial sovereignty, which is beyond the jurisdiction of an arbitral tribunal, a German expert has said.

Stefan Talmon, director of the Institute of Public International Law at the University of Bonn, said in a paper published recently that despite the Philippines' claims about issues such as "traditional fishing rights," the "actual controversy" in the case is about territorial sovereignty.

The Hague-based Arbitral Tribunal on the South China Sea established at the unilateral request of the Philippines has no jurisdiction over the case, as disputes over territorial sovereignty are not governed by the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), Talmon said.

The arbitral tribunal will issue a final award on July 12. China has repeatedly said that it will neither accept nor participate in the arbitration.

Talmon also criticized the tribunal for failing to scrutinize the documents referred to by the Philippines in its submission and ignoring China's position before rendering an award on Oct. 29, 2015 when it ruled that it has jurisdiction over the case.

"The tribunal's finding on the true nature of the dispute is based on a misunderstanding of the disputes in the South China Sea," he said, calling the tribunal's award on Oct. 29, 2015 an example of "discounted justice."

In a recent interview with Xinhua, Talmon said the coming award would not help solve the disputes over the South China Sea, but rather have a "counterproductive impact" on the issue.

"There is a danger that the decision will be misused for political purposes and ultimately contribute to the hardening of positions of both sides," he said.

[Editor: huaxia]
 
German expert doubts arbitral court's jurisdiction over South China Sea dispute
                 Source: Xinhua | 2016-07-04 09:51:12 | Editor: huaxia

BERLIN, July 3 (Xinhua) -- The real nature of a dispute between China and the Philippines over the South China Sea is about territorial sovereignty, which is beyond the jurisdiction of an arbitral tribunal, a German expert has said.

Stefan Talmon, director of the Institute of Public International Law at the University of Bonn, said in a paper published recently that despite the Philippines' claims about issues such as "traditional fishing rights," the "actual controversy" in the case is about territorial sovereignty.

The Hague-based Arbitral Tribunal on the South China Sea established at the unilateral request of the Philippines has no jurisdiction over the case, as disputes over territorial sovereignty are not governed by the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), Talmon said.

The arbitral tribunal will issue a final award on July 12. China has repeatedly said that it will neither accept nor participate in the arbitration.

Talmon also criticized the tribunal for failing to scrutinize the documents referred to by the Philippines in its submission and ignoring China's position before rendering an award on Oct. 29, 2015 when it ruled that it has jurisdiction over the case.

"The tribunal's finding on the true nature of the dispute is based on a misunderstanding of the disputes in the South China Sea," he said, calling the tribunal's award on Oct. 29, 2015 an example of "discounted justice."

In a recent interview with Xinhua, Talmon said the coming award would not help solve the disputes over the South China Sea, but rather have a "counterproductive impact" on the issue.

"There is a danger that the decision will be misused for political purposes and ultimately contribute to the hardening of positions of both sides," he said.

分享
Commentary: Loss outweighs gains for Japan's stubborn meddling in South China Sea
U.S. behind rising tension in South China Sea: S African commentator
Interview: Philippines disregards legal duty with call for South China Sea arbitration: S.Korean law professor
Commentary: UNCLOS unable to solve complicated South China Sea row
Consultation is way to keep peace, stability in South China Sea: Greek party official
Many regions in Anhui flooded due to heavy rainfall
Many regions in Anhui flooded due to heavy rainfall
Twelve miners trapped in Shanxi flooded mine
Twelve miners trapped in Shanxi flooded mine
Living standard of people keeps rising in Xigaze, China's Tibet
Living standard of people keeps rising in Xigaze, China's Tibet
E China's county becomes waterlogged due to torrential rainfall
E China's county becomes waterlogged due to torrential rainfall
Afro-descendant women pose for group photo in Uruguay
Afro-descendant women pose for group photo in Uruguay
Russian United Democratic Party "Yabloko" pre-election congress held
Russian United Democratic Party "Yabloko" pre-election congress held
Monsoon season brings ample rainfall in multiple cities of India
Monsoon season brings ample rainfall in multiple cities of India
New York's Central Park blast likely caused by "experiment" explosives: police
New York's Central Park blast likely caused by "experiment" explosives: police
Back to Top Close
010020070750000000000000011100001354868411